Manhattan Pawn Shop Owner Pleads Guilty in Stolen Luxury Goods Case

A pawn shop owner in Manhattan has admitted to knowingly buying and reselling stolen high-end items that were taken from affluent homes across the United States. The case gained national attention after it was linked to a burglary at Cincinnati Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow’s home while he was away for an NFL game.

Pawn Shop Tied to Widespread Theft Ring

Dimitriy Nezhinskiy, 44, from New Jersey, pleaded guilty to a federal conspiracy charge. He co-owned a pawn shop in Manhattan’s Diamond District and admitted to buying and reselling luxury items—including watches and jewelry—that were stolen from high-end homes across the country.

Although he accepted responsibility, Nezhinskiy claimed he didn’t know the items came from residential burglaries until after his arrest. In court, he said most of his business was legitimate and profitable. Now, he faces up to five years in federal prison, along with $2.5 million in restitution and the same amount in asset forfeiture.

Instagram | joeyb_9 | A Manhattan pawn shop owner admitted to reselling stolen high-end items from affluent homes, including Joe Burrow’s.

The pawn shop became a key link in a wider black-market chain. It helped move stolen goods from burglarized homes to resale shelves. New York City Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch called it a “deliberate operation” that made it easier for organized thieves to cash in on their crimes.

Connection to High-Profile Home Invasions

Although prosecutors didn’t charge Nezhinskiy with specific burglaries, investigators found clear links between him and a key suspect in the December 2024 break-in at Joe Burrow’s Ohio home. Just days before the burglary, Nezhinskiy communicated with two individuals believed to be part of the same theft crew.

The burglary teams usually struck when athletes and public figures were out of town, often during away games or scheduled events. Other high-profile targets included the homes of Patrick Mahomes and Travis Kelce from the Kansas City Chiefs, Luka Dončić of the Los Angeles Lakers, and Mike Conley Jr. of the Minnesota Timberwolves.

The December 9 burglary at Burrow’s home happened while the Bengals played in Dallas. A family acquaintance, later identified as model Olivia Ponton, discovered a shattered window and a ransacked interior. Authorities eventually arrested several suspects in connection with the break-in, finding stolen items including a Cincinnati Bengals cap, an LSU shirt, and jewelry marked with Burrow’s jersey number, “JB9.”

Seized Property Paints a Larger Picture

myfox28columbus.com | During the investigation, FBI agents found large amounts of suspected stolen property.

During the FBI investigation, agents uncovered large caches of suspected stolen property at Nezhinskiy’s pawn shop and in storage units under his name in New Jersey. The list included:

1. Luxury handbags and watches
2. Designer luggage and eyewear
3. Fine artwork and wine
4. Jewelry and rare sports memorabilia
5. Burglary tools and safe-cracking equipment

Prosecutors argue that the items strongly suggest the pawn shop functioned as a resale hub for stolen goods from 2020 until Nezhinskiy’s arrest in early 2025.

Juan Villar, a business associate who co-managed the pawn shop, also entered a guilty plea in June. His sentencing is scheduled for December. Authorities say both men worked with multiple theft crews — including international burglary rings made up of South American nationals who frequently traveled to commit these crimes.

Ongoing Legal Consequences

The court also noted that Nezhinskiy, a legal U.S. resident originally from Georgia, could face deportation. His sentencing date is still pending.

Although Nezhinskiy wasn’t formally charged in the burglary at Joe Burrow’s home, evidence shows he had contact with people linked to the crime. Phone records revealed communication with suspects just days before the break-in. The larger investigation has already led to at least six arrests in multiple states.

This case highlights how some businesses, like pawn shops, can become tools for organized crime. When owners fail to check the source of high-end goods, they risk supporting illegal resale networks. The Nezhinskiy investigation shows just how far stolen property can travel—from a break-in in Ohio to a display case in New York City.